Celtic Memorial: The Hermitage Cemetery, Fredericton
By James M. Whalen

On 24 September 2000, Monsignor Brian H. Henneberry, Pastor of St Dunstan’s Church, unveiled a Celtic memorial at the Hermitage Cemetery in Fredericton honoring the memory of some of the earliest Roman Catholic parishioners – mostly Irish – who were buried in St Dunstan’s Cemetery between 1836 and 1870. The money for the memorial came out of funds from the sale of St Dunstan’s School that stands on ground where the old cemetery was located.
It is fitting to honor the early Irish Catholic presence in Fredericton that by 1871 was significant. As historian, Peter Toner, has so clearly shown: “There were a few pockets in southwestern New Brunswick where the Irish were mainly Catholic. The City of Fredericton is an example. It was just under half Irish and these were almost 60 % Catholic. The adjacent rural areas shared this distribution.” 1
The memorial in the Hermitage Cemetery actually consists of several components. The centerpiece is a suitably engraved Celtic cross – similar to the one marking the nearby grave of Rt. Rev. William Dollard, the first Roman Catholic Bishop of New Brunswick.2 Then, there are six tablets – three on either side of this high cross bearing names such as: Breen, Dolan, Logue, McCann, O’Brien, Sullivan and Tierney, as well as their year of death. Besides many “known only to God,” Monsignor Henneberry explained “in a very special way, we commemorate the 283 people who were originally buried in the old cemetery on Regent Street, whose remains were moved here in 1910 …” 3 Lastly, a monument, called a “slope marker,” installed directly in line with the Celtic cross, is engraved with the names of eight priests whose graves are close by.
Arranged alphabetically, the names etched on the memorial were compiled mainly from archival and church records and from James Hannay’s “Report on Burying Grounds in New Brunswick.” Before having the names inscribed, Monsignor Henneberry posted a list of them in St.Dunstan’s Church seeking information as to their accuracy but apparently no one suggested any changes.
Unfortunately, those using the memorial for genealogical purposes might have difficulty in identifying the names of some married women. Those recorded in church records and thus on the memorial are mostly married names but in the cases of Anne Bradley, Bridget Bradley and Nancy McGlinn, for example, they are their maiden names.4 Moreover, the wrong prename of Bishop Thomas L.Connolly’s father is engraved on one of the tablets. Undoubtedly, this happened because James Hannay inadvertently put the name “Jane Connolly” instead of “James Connolly” in his 1908 cemetery report. Small wonder that based on this source this error occurred again. 5
The Hermitage property, where the new memorial stands, dates from 1870 when Rev. James C. McDevitt purchased this beautiful site along the Woodstock Road for a burial ground and for other church related purposes. Almost immediately, it became known as the “new Catholic Cemetery.” The former burial ground at St Dunstan’s – referred to as the “old Catholic Cemetery”- was supposedly closed then. Nonetheless, a few burials, especially of those who had close relatives there, took place after its closure. This accounts for names such as Ann Densmore, John Long, Dennis O’Leary and Richard Tobin, all whom died after 1870, on the memorial.
The Hermitage estate and the buildings that once stood on it originally belonged to Hon.Thomas Baillie, who served as Commissioner of Crown Lands and Surveyor General of New Brunswick in the early nineteenth century. Eventually, Baillie went bankrupt and lost the property. Then, William F. Odell acquired it and bequeathed it to his daughter, Elizabeth – Baillie’s second wife. Subsequently, Father McDevitt bought it from Elizabeth Baillie – by then a widow – and her family at a cost of four thousand dollars.6
The memorial erected in the Hermitage Cemetery in the year 2000 was long over due. In fact, it was ninety years before when parishioners of St Dunstan’s voted in favor of using the Regent Street cemetery site for a school. 7 It was then that most of the graves and markers in the path of school construction were moved. According to Fredericton author, Ruth Scott: “the remains of the old graveyard were reverently lifted and re-interred in the new cemetery on the Woodstock Road, now known as the Hermitage. To provide a schoolyard for the children, the remaining gravestones were removed and placed in the Hermitage as well.” 8
Dr. Hannay listed the tombstones in St Dunstan’s Cemetery in his1908 report but very few of these exist today. For example, the headstones for Rev. Michael McSweeney, Lawrence Neville and his wife Mary, as well as that of Mary Friel, wife of John Carten, were moved and are now in the Hermitage Cemetery but not many others. Some were broken or went missing, including an eight-foot marble tombstone over the grave of Private John Brennan, who was murdered in Fredericton in 1868. 9
Long after St Dunstan’s School opened, early in 1911, questions sometimes arose whenever locals, including school children, found broken tombstones and human remains on or near school property. Eventually, most everything was dug up in the former graveyard and transferred to the Hermitage Cemetery or else it deteriorated to the point where today there is virtually nothing left.10
A portion of the original Hermitage property, now consisting of about eight and one-half acres, is at present a well-kept Roman Catholic graveyard. Originally, this land was located on the outskirts of Fredericton but now is within city limits. Situated near the Saint John River and adjoining the Protestant Rural Cemetery, the graveyard known as “The Hermitage” is the main place for Catholic burials in Fredericton and surrounding area. Among those buried there are many descendants of the nearly three hundred, mainly Irish Catholic parishioners of the capital city and vicinity, whose names are so deservedly honored on the memorial.
James M Whalen
ICCANB, Fredericton Chapter
15 January 2008
1 Peter M Toner, “Another New Ireland Lost: The Irish of New Brunswick” The Untold Story: The Irish in Canada, ed., Robert O’Driscoll and Lorna Reynolds, 1988, Vol. 1, p 232
2 Bishop Dollard’s remains were originally buried in the sanctuary of St Dunstan’s Church but they were moved to the Hermitage Cemetery when that church was demolished to make way for a new one. It is interesting to note that in July 2000 an accident occurred at the contractors’ workshop –Tingley Monuments Limited, Amherst – causing the Celtic cross to break into several pieces and it had to be replaced (Brochure entitled ”Jubilee Commemoration of the Faithful Departed, The Hermitage Cemetery, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Twenty Fourth Day of September in the Great Jubilee Year of Our Lord 2000.”)
3 Remarks of Monsignor Brian H Henneberry, “Jubilee Commemoration of the Faithful Departed, The Hermitage Cemetery, Fredericton, New Brunswick” The 283 names on the memorial represent just some of the people who were buried in St Dunstan’s cemetery. Due to the incompleteness of earlier church records, it is not known how many burials actually took place there but it is thought that there were a great many more.
4 Besides church records, information about these women is available from newspapers of the day. For example, Anne Bradley died in 1869. She was the widow of Dennis Sullivan. (See: the Royal Gazette, Fredericton, 1 Aug 1838); Bridget Bradley died in 1845. She was married to William Owens (See; the New Brunswick Courier, Saint John, 17 June 1843 and 18 Oct 1845); and Nancy McGlinn died in 1845. She was married to Thomas Buchanan (See: the Royal Gazette, Fredericton, 09 Nov 1836. Both parties were from Douglas Parish, York County).
5 James Hannay, Report on Burying Grounds in New Brunswick, 1908. This source was relied upon because records of death for St Dunstan’s Church are missing for this period. By the way, James Connolly, a native of Fermanagh, Ireland died on 14 Dec 1839, aged 56.
6 New Brunswick Museum, F40, Odell Family Collection, William H Odell, Estate of Elizabeth Baillie. Sale of the Hermitage, Fredericton, to Father James C. McDevitt, 1870, 3 pgs.
7 Daily Gleaner, Fredericton, 16 Feb 1910
8 Ruth Scott, “The Hermitage: Historic Property by the River,” The Officers’ Quarterly, Fredericton, Spring 1996, p.13. Also refer to W. Austin Squires, History of Fredericton, The Last 200 Years, Fredericton, 1980, p168.
9 James Hannay, Report on Burying Grounds in New Brunswick, 1908 and Ted Jones, Fredericton Flashback, Halifax, 2003, pp. 144 –149. The latter work contains an account of Brennan’s murder.
10 It seems that far too often the practice is to clean up broken fragments of tombstones without attempting to patch them together. Without proper care, the identity of a marker can be lost forever.